blog posts

the Alexander syndrome

When Alexander saw the breadth of his domain, he wept for there were no more worlds to conquer.

My 30th birthday is coming up in the next few months and it’s caused me to reflect on something I think is pretty prevalent among pastors my age (and perhaps just people in general, but I’m seeing it more and more in pastors). Because of our uber-connected digital world, we have the privilege of hearing more and more stories of people leading churches or planting churches and their successes and failures.

Mostly, however, we gravitate towards the success stories. This seems pretty natural, right?

Now I’ve noticed there is something strange that happens with some of these stories. There are a few “success” stories that most people seem to know and a certain mythos develops around them. They become ingrained in our brain in very subtle ways and I think we consciously and unconsciously reference them. Rob Bell starts Mars Hill and 1500 people show up the first week with no advertising. Mark Driscoll starts a Mars Hill of his own and finds wild success. Bill Hybels has 5 couples all throw their credit cards on a table and max them out to start Willow Creek. Andy Stanley. Steven Furtick. Perry Noble.

Now what I’ve been thinking about is how these stories, which most pastors within evangelical culture have heard, are shaping the way we are thinking and behaving.

Here’s what I mean: Most of these pastors saw very quick, massive and unprecedented (and I’d suggest unreproducible) growth at the outset (in the sense that it was the right message, the right atmosphere, the right spiritual climate, the right voice, at the right time. Go anywhere else at a different time and it wouldn’t happened again). And within three years, these guys were overnight successes.

And for the most part…they were all around the age of 30. Some a little younger, some a little older, all having conquered the their respective worlds.

Just like Alexander the Great.

(hence why I’ve started to refer to this as the Alexander Syndrome)

My contention is that because these kinds of stories have become cultural norms in our pastoral, evangelical sub-culture, we’ve placed certain expectations on ourselves, our churches and our people to get our churches to have these kinds of stories by the time we’ve reached a certain age. And if we’ve passed that age…we feel like we’re “behind.”

In fact, I’ve got several friends who are all around the age of 30 or a little older who are just getting started leading something substantial within a church, it’s still “small” (whatever that means), and have said, “I don’t know…I just feel…behind…like everyone’s ahead of me.” For me, I know I’ve fought this in the last 5 years. I don’t know that I ever said it out loud or even consciously thought it, but one day, I caught myself feeling like I was on some sort of invisible timetable and it all linked back to these stories.

I think it’s about the Alexander Sydrome.

I think we’ve come to believe that if our churches or whatever we’re leading don’t ‘POP’ like these kinds of stories, somehow we are failing, we’re behind and we’ve got work harder, press harder, make up lost ground.

More pressure. More frenetic living. More stress.

(***I’m choosing not to even touch the fact that our soul responsibility is to be obedient and to leave outcomes in God’s hands.)

Over and over I’m starting to see this in younger pastors. This, “I’ve got to make my mark and conquer the church world by the time I’m 30″ kind of thinking. And I think we’re foolish if we don’t think this is forming us spiritually and shaping the way we lead and behave. If I’m right, it has to be shaping us like that.

How about you? Are you seeing this? Am I sitting alone on this one?

 

 

Digg This
Reddit This
Stumble Now!
Buzz This
Vote on DZone
Share on Facebook
Bookmark this on Delicious
Kick It on DotNetKicks.com
Shout it
Share on LinkedIn
Bookmark this on Technorati
Post on Twitter
Google Buzz (aka. Google Reader)

Subscribe

Enter your email address to subscribe to Doug's blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

5 Responses to the Alexander syndrome

  1. Ben Sternke 2011/03/07 at 3:41 pm #

    The attitude you describe is definitely alive and well, unfortunately. Partly to blame is our celebrity culture, where certain people are elevated as examples (usually for all the wrong reasons). But mostly to blame is good old-fashioned pride, which goes unchecked and uncalled-out because people don’t have the first clue what it means to be a disciple of Jesus; they just want to be seen by others as “successful” or “anointed” or what have you.

    Jesus’ words from the Sermon on the Mount about the “hypocrites” come to mind: “I tell you the truth, they have their reward in full.” But if we really engage with the deep issues of our heart, allowing the Lord to confront pride, desire for praise, lust for attention, etc… our Father, who sees what is done in secret, will reward us.

    A good thing to think about as we head into Lent this week!

  2. Jason Hess 2011/03/08 at 4:34 am #

    I’ve struggled with this. When I was in full-time youth ministry I always found myself looking at my peers who had explosive youth ministries. Something just clicked for them like it never clicked for me… or so I felt.

    Playing the comparison game definitely did me more harm than good. If I may, here’s an excerpt from a recent post from my sight (Identity Crisis)…

    “If I may confess, throughout my Christian walk, especially as a minister and even more so while in full-time ministry, I found myself comparing my circumstances to others. Wondering how that guy could be my age and yet lead a thriving busting at the seams ministry while I was struggling to breathe hope into a handful. Thinking like that totally destroys any sense of… impact. All it does is bear fruit of dis-satisfaction, jealousy and sometimes regret.”

    The comparison game is one of the most destructive things a pastor… a believer… anyone can engage in.

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. The stories we’re buying into (and may not know about) — Doug Paul - 2011/03/09

    [...] few days ago I wrote a post on what I call the Alexander Syndrome (you can read it here), which has me thinking a lot about all of the subtle things that we as pastors come to accept as [...]

  2. For Church Leaders: Is 50 the new 30? - 2013/01/05

    [...] year I wrote a post called “The Alexander Syndrome” that’s been coming back to my mind [...]

Leave a Reply

Connect with: